A pizza in Australia’s Posh Pizza has everyone whispering, “Holy Cheesus!”

Pizza maker Maree Phelan said she topped the pizza with cheese as usual, threw it in the oven and discovered the face of Jesus looking back at her when she took it out.

Phelan insists that it’s not a fake and that the cheese pizzas crafted by Posh always turn out differently. Though some say the pie also bears a resemblance to a long-haired Christian Bale or the lead singer of Stillwater,Russell, in Almost Famous but the crown of thorns is hard to miss.

Posh Pizza put the divine pizza on eBay to raise money for charity. It drew in 26 bids and $153.