In one corner, we have Mountain Dew, the soft drink heavily rooted in extreme sports, like surfing, skiing and snowboarding, and challenges you to “do the Dew.” According to PepsiCo lawyers, it also has the ability to turn mice into jelly!

In the other, we have Dr. Pepper, the “one of a kind,” oldest major soft drink in America that’s currently celebrating all that makes its drinkers special and unique. In addition, its sibling soda Dr. Pepper TEN is apparently so manly that “it’s not for women.”

So, which is better? It’s now time for you to decide in our poll below.