Cheyenne’s Five Most Infamous Ghost Stories
Ever since the Union Railroad Railroad arrived in 1867, Cheyenne has been a haven for miners, gunslingers, gamblers, and rugged frontiersmen looking to stake a claim.
According to some folks, many of those early settlers still haunt the Capital City to this day. Here are five of Cheyenne's most infamous ghost stories
The Atlas Theatre Preacher – This historic landmark was constructed in 1887 and originally housed a candy shop on the ground floor before being converted into a theater in 1908.
Over the years, hundreds have witnessed what they claim are two ghosts that occupy the building.
One local legend, reported on the website Hauntedhouses.com, attributes the ghosts to a preacher who had opened a church in the building, only to discover that his wife was moonlighting as a lady of the evening. The preacher allegedly killed his wife and then hung himself in the theatre.
Rosie at The Plains Hotel – When this downtown landmark first opened in 1911, it was considered to be the most luxurious hotel in the region. Legend has it, one of the guests in the early days of the hotel was a woman named Rosie who was honeymooning with her new husband.
During their stay, Rosie found her groom in the arms of a prostitute and shot them both in the woman’s room on the fourth floor. She later turned the gun on herself in the Honeymoon Suite.
Visitors have seen the ghost of the groom all over the hotel. Many also claim the other woman still haunts the second floor. Meanwhile, Rosie has been spotted in and around the Honeymoon Suite.
The St. Mark’s Mason – This historic church is said to be haunted by the ghost of a man who fell to his death during the construction of its iconic bell tower.
Although the church was originally built in the 1880s, the tower wasn’t completed until 1924. Two of the stonemasons reportedly vanished before the project was complete. One man later returned, claiming his partner had fallen to his death. In a panic, the man covered up the body inside the bell tower.
Since then, visitors have reported strange noises coming from within the tower walls, including the sound of hammering.
The Deming School Ghost – This historic art-deco building on West 5th Avenue was constructed in 1945.
For decades, witnesses have encountered the ghost a man who died in the furnace room. Some folks even believe that if you look into a window at night, you will see two reflections; yours and the ghost’s.
The Ghost of Judge Blume – Fred Blume served as a justice on the Wyoming Supreme Court from 1922 until 1963.
Many believe his ghost still lives in the building. The spirit has been known to turn on lights at night and there have also been numerous reports of cigar smoke coming from the office that Judge Blume once occupied.